How a verdict is made

Methodology and sources

Battery Codebook separates physical similarity from electrical equivalence and keeps evidence beside the answer.

Evidence hierarchy

Current manufacturer datasheets and selection guides are preferred for identity, dimensions, nominal voltage, chemistry and drain designation. Official government and public-safety authorities control emergency routes. Retailer tables may identify a question, but do not become the factual source.

Every supported claim records publisher, document title, URL, location, checked date, reviewer confidence and reuse restriction. Conflicting facts remain unresolved until a reviewer can compare current primary documents.

Canonical-family rule

Evidence-backed aliases such as LR44, A76 and AG13 resolve to one canonical record. They do not receive separate indexable pages. Another family is evaluated as a relationship, not silently added as an alias.

Four relationship classes

  1. Exact equivalent: both codes resolve to the same canonical family.
  2. Conditional substitute: the physical envelope may match and the electrical family may agree, but a W/SW drain designation differs and the device requirement must control.
  3. Same size, different electrical family: dimensions match, but chemistry or nominal voltage differs. Fit alone does not establish substitution.
  4. Not equivalent: a material physical or electrical mismatch, including a different height, prevents a defensible substitution claim.

Review, dates and corrections

A checked date changes after factual verification, not a cosmetic edit. Sources are reviewed on the maintenance cycle and sooner after a material correction. A correction should identify the page, disputed field, primary source and date checked.

Battery Codebook is independent of manufacturers and standards bodies. Source links acknowledge evidence; they do not imply endorsement. Use the contact and corrections route to see how to submit a correction.

Conflicts, confidence and exclusions

High confidence means the canonical identity and core specification are supported by a current manufacturer datasheet or selection guide, with corroboration where available. Medium confidence is reserved for a claim with a narrower or less direct primary route; it is never silently promoted to High.

When current primary sources disagree, the disputed field is not converted into an equivalence claim. The reviewer records the conflict and seeks a newer product-specific document. Obsolete, regional, rechargeable, industrial-pack and unsupported retailer-only codes are deliberately excluded from the public canonical catalogue until their identity and specifications can be defended.

Visible source hierarchy

PrioritySource typeUse
1Current product datasheetDimensions, chemistry, voltage and product test conditions
2Manufacturer selection or cross-reference guideAliases, W/SW classes and corroboration
3Official safety authorityEmergency and handling routes only
ExcludedRetailer or unsourced tableQuestion discovery, never the final factual basis

See the policy applied on the LR621 / AG1, SR1130SW / 390 and CR2032 records. The maintained provenance ledger records each canonical record’s claim scope, publisher, document, location, checked date, confidence and any unresolved conflict.

Last reviewed 2 September 2026.